The most common question is which brushes are better, framed or frameless? There is no single answer to this question. The rating includes both those and others. In addition, hybrid models are on the list of the best. All of them have their advantages and disadvantages.
Wiper blades are one of the most frequently changed consumables in a car: you often have to install new ones even on cars that have just left a car dealership; on many state employees, regular wipers do not suit drivers much. Well, let's try to figure out how this simple item works and by what principle you need to choose the best set of wipers.
Brushes of the modern type were invented almost a hundred years ago - in 1923. Since then, their device has changed little: the working element is an elastic band with a sharp edge, fixed in an elastic bracket for attaching to a leash. The elasticity of the brush is its main quality, which directly affects the cleaning efficiency, since when moving, the edge of the brush should fit as closely as possible to the curved surface of the glass.
Depending on the type of suspension in the bracket, the brushes are divided into:
- Frame- in them, the supporting structure itself is the elastic element. The brush frame is connected to the cleaning plate at several points, trying to bend it. Hence and main disadvantage frame brushes: they adhere most closely to the glass at the points of connection with the frame.
- Frameless brushes as an elastic element use a metal plate, poured into the brush itself. Technologically, their manufacture is more complicated and expensive, but this is justified by a much better fit and, accordingly, effective work. A distinctive feature of frameless brushes is a concise appearance: the mount is located on the plastic frame of the brush itself.
- hybrid the brushes have both a supporting frame and an additional elastic element in the plate. For glasses with a large curvature of the surface, they will probably become the best choice. It is easy to distinguish them by the plastic casing that covers the frame and at the same time serves as an aerodynamic element.
The brush itself can be made from a variety of materials, the requirements for which are simple: elasticity, low coefficient of friction (this will ensure not only the absence of creaking, but also reduce edge abrasion), resistance to de-icing reagents, solvents (the main component of the washer is isopropyl alcohol ) and UV exposure. The rubber that was originally used for this is not very suitable for the specified parameters - in the cold it becomes stiffer, which is especially sensitive for frame brushes, it quickly cracks, and due to the high coefficient of friction it is prone to creaking. Modern materials silicone-based allow you to create more best brushes windshield wipers that can work both in summer and in severe frost.
When choosing brushes, you should take into account the peculiarities of car operation - in summer, budget frame brushes will be no less effective than premium hybrid models. But in the northern regions, in cities where anti-icing agents are actively used, the quality of the brush material and its design require more careful attention: here expensive “hybrids” definitely win in all respects.
Many motorists have absolutely no idea which wiper to choose for their car. In this case, the main criterion is often the price (the cheaper the better), which is a gross mistake.
At the first rain or snowfall, budget wipers will not cope with the task, and this, in turn, will increase the risk of getting into an accident.
Remember that your life and the lives of pedestrians largely depend on the quality of the windshield wipers, so saving is inappropriate here.
Classification
Modern wipers for a car come in three types - frame (classic), frameless and hybrid. Each of them has its pros and cons, which you must be aware of when choosing.
Let's consider them in more detail.
Frame wipers - a classic type of windshield wipers, which was installed on all domestic cars.
Their feature is the presence of a strong base, to which a special rubber band is attached. The frame design is made taking into account the size and curvature of the windshield.
The quality of the tape depends on the composition of the rubber, the accuracy of geometric dimensions, as well as the presence of additional coatings.
Special plates are inserted on the sides of the tape, which ensure an even distribution of force and maintain a certain shape of the wiper.
Rocker arms are responsible for the fit of the wipers.
Modern frame wipers may have spoilers that improve aerodynamics and reduce the noise level during operation of the device.
Windshield wipers with a closed rubber cover are becoming increasingly popular.
The advantage of frame wipers is good rigidity and high-quality fit of the rubber to the glass over the entire surface.
But there are also disadvantages.
When buying a device with low quality plastic, the latter can be destroyed under the influence of negative weather conditions, shells and cracks often appear.
The result - large backlashes and a decrease in the quality of cleaning windshield.
These car wipers are distinguished by the absence of an external metal frame. Most often they look like a plastic (or plastic-rubber) case, inside of which there are two metal plates.
By shape this species the windshield wiper looks like a spoiler. In the center of the product, a fastening is provided, along the edges - special plugs.
Advantages of frameless windshield wipers include:
- high-quality pressing to the glass, this is a guarantee of high quality cleaning even in bad weather;
- the best aerodynamics. Air resistance is greatly reduced, noise is reduced;
- the appearance of ice on the surface is excluded, which is especially important when operating a car in winter.
Among the disadvantages of frameless wipers can be noted:
- high price;
- difficulties with choosing the necessary fastening, because modern brushes can have a dozen different fasteners;
- the need to select wipers for a specific car model (due to design features).
Consequently, it does not always make sense to overpay for frameless wipers, because traditional products do just as well.
Hybrid wipers have the most advanced design. The developers managed to combine the classic design of frame (with hinges and rocker arms) and frameless wipers.
Thanks to the correct layout, we managed to make compact wipers with a small casing.
Unlike the frame hybrid windshield wipers are universal and can fit any car model. This ensures maximum clamping force. Thanks to the plastic casing, the device is reliably protected from dirt, water and dust.
The special aerodynamic design reduces lift and improves windshield cleaning.
It is believed that these wipers for the car will be installed on all modern cars in a few years.
The advantage of such wipers is good downforce, tight contact with the windshield, versatility and minimum height.
Disadvantages - possible snow build-up during heavy snowfalls and the high price, which scares away many motorists today.
Most modern cars are equipped with two wipers. At the same time, the sizes of the "driver" and "passenger" wipers may differ or be the same (it all depends on the wishes of the motorist).
In recent years, it has become increasingly popular to install a longer "driver's" windshield wiper. For example, on some Mitsubishi models, two wipers with sizes of 650 and 350 mm are suitable.
As for Daewoo Lanos, it is best for him to buy products of the same length (475 mm each).
Of course, the more area the wiper covers, the better. But when choosing the length, it is necessary to take into account the features of the windshield of the car, its parameters.
The same owners of Daewoo Lanos often go to the experiment and install brushes measuring 500 + 450 mm. In this case, the maximum coverage is obtained.
In any case, if you do not know which wiper to choose, measure the size already installed brush and figure out how much its length can be increased.
Other selection criteria
Naturally, length is far from the only criterion for choosing windshield wipers; it is very important to focus on parameters such as:
1. Fastening.
- The most popular option is the hook. Products with such fasteners can be bought at almost any automotive store.
- In addition, there are such types of fasteners as a wide hook, side clamp, bayonet, side pin, button and others.
- Particular attention must be paid to fastening when choosing frameless wipers (we already mentioned this above).
2. Appearance is also an important aspect.
- Here it is necessary to pay attention to the absence of cracks in the body and rubber brush, burrs and other damage. Some windshield wipers have sensors that indicate wear. Of course, the sensor has a certain error, but this is not so scary.
3. The quality of the gum.
- It is very important that this structural element has the necessary frost resistance and is immune to various liquids. It is worth paying attention to the composition of the rubber bands. Today, more and more often, graphite is added to rubber, and silicone is added to rubber.
Most often, such brushes have a frameless design, but unlike their " younger brothers”, they do not lose elasticity in any weather and are able to independently solve the problem of surface icing.
But these brushes have two obvious drawbacks - the complexity of installation and the price, which is slightly higher than conventional wipers.
By the way, we should not forget about such an inconvenience as the need to connect the brushes to the on-board network, which causes a number of difficulties (you have to choose a place, tighten the wires, carefully lay them, and so on).
But still, you can’t do without a full-fledged warming up of the cabin and blowing warm air on the surface in winter.
conclusions
That's all, now you know how to choose wipers for a car, what types of wipers are and what are their features.
We remember this element of the car only in bad weather and rarely take into account that right choice can not only facilitate the trip, but also save you from an accident.
Comparison of frameless and frame wipers - video.
The end of winter marked the beginning of the wet season, and many, having torn their brushes on the ice crust on the windshield for winter months Thinking about replacing wipers. Today we deal with simple question what kind of wipers are in general, and by what parameters to choose them.
1. What needs to be done?
Select wiper blades to replace worn ones.
2. What parameters should be observed when choosing new brushes?
By by and large, there are three parameters that may differ when choosing new brushes. Wipers should be selected according to the following criteria:
- length: new brushes should be the same length as the ones available and recommended for your model;
- attachment type: new brushes must have the same type of attachment as the old ones;
- design is already a matter of taste and price, and we will consider it in the next paragraph.
A couple more remarks about the first two points. Speaking about the recommended length of wipers, it is worth remembering that sometimes it is possible to install wipers a little longer than those recommended by the manufacturer on a car. Take a look at the gap between the brushes in the rest position and the area being cleaned by each of them - if the gap is large, and the cleaning area does not reach the edges of the windshield, you can try on a brush a few centimeters longer. The main thing here is that the brushes do not touch each other during operation: this will cause unnecessary wear on the trapezium of the wipers and the mechanism as a whole.
As for the type of attachment, their classification is almost a topic for an entire article. Over the years of evolution, so many types of wiper mounts have divorced that it becomes unclear why this is needed now. The good news is that, as a rule, a whole mountain of adapters is included with the brushes, designed to install the wipers on a leash with almost any type of attachment. Of course, even in such conditions there are "unique" mounts, brushes for which you have to look for. But the most obvious decision when planning to replace the brushes is to simply remove the existing wiper, see what type of mount your car uses, and see if it's listed on the adapters list on the packaging of the new kit. In 95% of cases, there are no problems with the search.
3. What are the designs of wipers?
This is exactly the third item from the previous list, which is not critical, but depends on your preferences and budget. Note that we will not take into account exotic options like heated wipers, but consider ordinary mass brushes, which make up 99% of the market.
In general, modern wipers are divided into three types:
- frame;
- frameless;
- hybrid.
Frame wipers- these are those that have been familiar to everyone for a long time: they have a metal or plastic frame with rocker arms, and the glass is cleaned by a polymer brush fixed on two metal guides. Their advantages stem from their age and design: they are the cheapest, and the design provides maximum adhesion to the glass even in the bend area. Cons - from the same place: the more mechanical parts in the design, the more it is subject to wear, and in winter the frame of the wipers is covered with ice, ceasing to fulfill its direct duties of “fitting” the glass.
Frameless wipers- these are the same two metal guides holding the cleaning element, but no longer on the frame, but in a plastic case. Such a janitor keeps its shape precisely due to the bending of the metal insert, and it will no longer bend more than it is. Therefore, strongly convex glasses there is a risk of getting uncleaned corners. But there is no mechanics here: it is a one-piece element, and only the directly cleaning surface wears out. Accordingly, the frosting of the brush is minimal, and the one-piece design also has a positive effect on the noise background - usually frameless brushes are given an aerodynamically favorable shape. That's just to pay for a frameless janitor will need more than for the "ancient" frame.
hybrid wipers- this is a combination of the best qualities from the first and second types. They have a frame with rocker arms, which ensures a good fit of the cleaning strip to the glass, and they also have a developed plastic casing that covers this frame. The brush turns out to be efficient, heavy and solid, and thanks to the same aerodynamic shape, it presses even harder against the glass on high speeds. But you have to pay for all this splendor, almost like a pair of frame and demon frame wiper separately.
subspecies hybrid brushes you can also consider the so-called "winter" wipers. This is also a frame structure, but completely hidden in a sealed casing that prevents the ingress of water and snow and the accompanying freezing. Of the pluses - softer cleaning elements, designed for low temperatures, and a decent service life. Of the minuses - the size is even larger than that of hybrid brushes, the need to replace brushes seasonally and pay for them as for a "specialized" thing.
4. When should you change your brushes?
This question is much simpler than it might seem: you yourself will see and feel that it's time for the brushes to be in the trash. It is worth remembering corny that wipers are consumables, and their service life rarely exceeds a couple of seasons. If the wipers do not remove water and dirt after one or two strokes, smearing stains on the glass, there is nothing to explain. Another unpleasant feature of poor-quality or worn-out brushes can be a water film that remains after the cleaning element passes through the glass: in the rain at night, this film “smeares” the headlights of oncoming cars, critically worsening visibility. Of course, the janitor cannot remove the water dry, but if you feel obvious disadvantage visibility, and you are blinded by every oncoming car, this may be a reason to stop by the store for new couple brushes.
Before buying wipers for your car, you should familiarize yourself with their characteristics. To avoid unpleasant situations on the road, you need to see it well, which means that the cleanliness of the windshield must be perfect. And this will help us achieve high-quality wipers for cars. And for winter and summer they should be different. Although many motorists neglect this rule.
Properly selected wipers will allow us to provide the necessary visibility through the front and rear windows of the car. Therefore, the process of choosing wipers should be given Special attention, after all, low-quality wipers will not cope with their duties as they should. But few people know how to choose the right wipers, what parameters to pay attention to. IN modern world we are offered huge selection manufacturers and it is very difficult to understand the quality and purpose of the goods. Therefore, here are some tips from professionals on how to choose wipers and not make a mistake.
First, let's figure out how winter wipers differ from summer wipers.
There is no doubt that there is a difference between winter and summer wipers. Windshield wipers designed for use in winter are made of rubber, which copes much better with snow and icing. It remains more elastic under the influence of negative temperatures. All of this is due to the fact that windshield wiper manufacturers use a special rubber design and composition that overcomes all of the above problems about once, since the surface of the wiper repels water.
How to choose the right wipers
From what we talked about above, we can conclude that windshield wipers, in relation to weather conditions, are divided into three main types:
- summer, those that are designed to work at positive temperatures;
- winter, those that do their job well in minus temperature and in snowy weather;
- universal - wipers that are equally good at cleaning glass at any temperature and at any weather conditions, but as a rule their price "bites".
Wipers designed for use in summer time, are made of less elastic rubber. Although at positive temperatures, you will not feel much difference between winter and summer. Winter wipers are more expensive, so it is impractical to use them in summer. For the summer period, you can use cheaper wipers, and for the winter it is better to put frameless ones.
When buying wipers, so that they serve as long as possible, you should pay attention to the following things:
- First of all, it is the quality of rubber;
- secondly, the wipers must be the same length;
- the kit should have mounts suitable for any car;
- And fourth, the price is right.
If you don't care about everything important factors, then purchasing wipers that are right for you, which will last as long as possible and without complaints, becomes not such a difficult matter.
What are the wipers
We have already found out that there are winter, summer and universal wipers, but in addition to this, depending on the design, they can also be divided into frameless, frame and hybrid.
To decide which wipers are best suited for your car, and which ones it is advisable not to purchase at all, let's look at the most popular types of windshield wipers:
- frameless wipers;
- frame wipers or summer;
- winter wipers;
- hybrid wipers.
Each type differs from each other in the principle of impact on the windshield or rear window, as a rule, the difference in pressure. Let's figure out what distinguishes one species from another that distinguishes these types from each other.
Frameless wipers
Home hallmark frameless wipers is the absence of hinges in their design, which fails, for example, during icing. They also have good aerodynamics. They do not warp at decent speeds. These wipers also work quite silently. Another plus is the ease of replacing old rubber bands with new ones. Buying new rubber bands is cheaper than buying a whole wiper.
The disadvantages of this type of wipers include, perhaps, only the lack of versatility. Such wipers will need to be selected according to specific brand auto.
Advantages of frameless wipers in operation:
- it is easy to understand when to change the rubber bands, thanks to the presence of an indicator strip, which signals us in advance that a replacement will soon be required;
- thanks to low profile such a brush increases visibility, and this, you see, is a considerable advantage;
- thanks to the hingeless design, they easily endure snowy winters and icing of windows;
- at speed, the rubber is pressed against the glass more strongly, due to aerodynamic properties, which means that the glass will be cleaned better;
- cope well with the cleaning of glass with curvature due to the uniform pressing force;
- frameless wipers do not have metal elements, and therefore are not sensitive to rust, which also positively affects the appearance;
- these windshield wipers have a beautiful design and look great on the windshield or rear window car of any class;
- let's repeat. The main advantage is their design, in which there are no hinges that periodically interfere with work.
Cons of frameless wipers
High-quality frameless wipers are in a fairly high price category. If you find such wipers at a low price, as a rule, this means that they are made of poor quality material or there is a fake. Therefore, you should not opt for frameless wipers at a tasty price.
Frame type wipers
These are classic wipers. As a rule, these wipers are designed for operation in the summer. Have a very simple design. They consist of curved rocker arms, elastic bands and certain hinged supports. Once upon a time, hinges were made of metal, which was extremely impractical in cold weather or in a humid environment, as they did not hold their shape well, and the integrity of the structure was violated. And all this reduced the operational period.
Today's frame wipers are equipped with axles and bushings that have plastic components, which makes it easier to clean the mechanism of snow or ice, they do not rust. But, if you want the frame wipers to serve you to the maximum, then use them in the summer, as they do their job perfectly in warm conditions.
In the case of frame wipers, price is of great importance. As a rule, a low price of a product means low quality. If your windshield wipers do not do a good job of cleaning the glass, because of the bad fit of the rubber to the glass, they creak and a crunch is heard - then you can be sure that these are very cheap wipers.
Models from a more expensive category will do a good job of cleaning glasses, thanks to the tight fit of the rubber to the glass, you will not be annoyed by squeaks and other extraneous sounds during the operation of the brushes.
But no matter how high-quality and expensive framed products are, they will all perform poorly in winter, especially when icing.
As a rule, more expensive windshield wipers can serve a year or more without complaints, which cannot be said about budget options.
Advantages of frame wipers
Despite the fact that frame wipers are considered summer, they perform well when severe frosts if icing is excluded.
They adapt well to different windshield surfaces thanks to the frame.
The presence of a plastic protective cover protects the hinges from dirt and dust.
Due to the fact that the frame is made of metal, they are quite durable (with the exception of some internal elements).
Replacing the rubber band is fairly easy.
As with other designs, framed windshield wipers have their drawbacks.
First of all, it is the appearance. After a certain period of work, frame wipers begin to rust. Which, you see, does not look very good.
Over time, the rocker arms wear out, which is why even with a new cleaning rubber, the grip on the glass will no longer be the same and you will notice flaws in cleaning the glass.
As mentioned above, they do not like snow and ice.
The biggest disadvantage, perhaps, can be considered the presence of mechanical hinges, because if they are damaged, then you can forget about the normal operation of the brushes.
Winter wipers
Optimal for winter conditions frame wipers are considered wipers, BUT equipped with special special covers, the task of which is to protect against freezing during snowfalls, so that the mechanism is protected and can function without problems. It is not advisable to use such brushes in the summer, as this protective cover creates additional resistance. At speeds over 90 km per hour, vibration will begin and noise will be heard.
As with previous windshield wipers, the quality of the winter option will also be related to the price. Therefore, in this option, it is better to pay once, but more expensive than to often change cheap brushes that quickly fail.
Hybrid car wipers
Such wipers are characterized by a low frame height, which is their main distinguishing feature from other types. In addition to a small frame, they also have a relatively small casing. Thanks to these features, hybrid windshield wipers have good aerodynamics. The wiper rubber fits tightly to the glass, which provides excellent cleaning from rain and snow.
Such wipers are purchased, as a rule, for cars with a large bulge of glass. They are quite expensive, but they do their job well for a long period of time.
They became popular due to the quality materials used in their manufacture. The presence of a high-density natural rubber insert makes the hybrid wipers resistant to mechanical breakdowns and various atmospheric phenomena.
Hybrid windshield wipers do their job well for the longest time. They are durable and strong. They can be used at any time of the year and they will show excellent results. But for all these pluses, you will undoubtedly have to fork out.
Benefits of hybrid wipers
- the gum fits snugly to the glass, thanks to the developed frame;
- the presence of a plastic case protects against adverse weather conditions and other contaminants;
- they are universal. Suitable for almost any car.
Cons of hybrid wipers
The most important and only negative that can affect the refusal to purchase is their cost!
How to extend the life of your windshield wipers
In order for your wipers to serve you as long as possible, you should adhere to the following rules:
- do not turn on the windshield wipers when the glass is dry or icy;
- it is not recommended to brush snow with wipers, you can damage the motor. To do this, use a scraper or brush, and already at the final stage, you can turn on the wipers;
- in freezing weather, to protect the rubber bands, do not allow the brushes to freeze to the glass. You just have to leave them up;
- do not forget to lubricate the hinges, most often they suffer first of all;
- Keep your windshield wipers clean of dust and dirt in a timely manner to protect the brushes from rust and the glass from scratches.
Conclusion
Windshield wipers, at first glance, an insignificant element. But quite a lot depends on them - after all, a good overview and visibility on the road is a guarantee of your safety and the safety of others. Therefore, do not forget to maintain and repair your brushes in a timely manner, and, if necessary, a complete replacement.
Based on the rules of the road, the driver should not operate the car with an inoperative windshield wiper. This requirement is especially relevant in winter, when the wiper blades are subject to high temperature and physical stress, and traffic safety depends on their normal operation, since poor (limited) visibility of the road can cause an accident.
This review presents the best auto wiper blades that can be purchased in domestic markets. For the convenience of the reader, the models are divided into typical categories. The rating position was formed on the basis of the parameters of these products, as well as the opinions and statements of the owners who left reviews on the network about their experience in operating a certain brand of wipers.
Best framed wiper blades
We start the review with representatives of the oldest type - frame brushes. These models are made in the form of a system of rocker arms and hinges on which the brush blade is fixed. This type is used on the vast majority of old cars, so for the owners of the "old men" the choice is obvious. When choosing, you should pay attention to the materials from which the movable elements are made. Although the metal is durable, in the conditions of our roads it quickly rusts and loses its elasticity. Plastic in this regard is preferable, although it can fail in severe frosts.
5 MTF light Classic U-Hook
Optimal ratio of quality and price
Country: South Korea
Average price: 270 rubles.
Rating (2019): 4.4
One of the most popular framed wiper blades combines high quality and low cost. The design of the wiper has an asymmetric design, thanks to which the oncoming wind presses the brush to the glass as tightly as possible, providing a better degree of cleaning. A kind of frame-spoiler is especially effective in winter, when the wipers are faced with a high load, brushing off snow or cleaning melting ice from the windshield of the car.
Owners who use this product on a regular basis note the high performance of MTF light Classic. In the reviews left, the silent operation of the wiper was positively assessed. The rubber band does not squeak at all even when moving on dry glass. Made from wear-resistant automotive rubber, the composition of which is a personal development of the company, the brush will last a long time and provide reliable removal of dirt, both in the summer and in the winter months.
4 Mui Champ
The most effective glass clamp
Country: Japan
Average price: 700 rubles.
Rating (2019): 4.5
Wiper blade Mui-Champ 022 550 mm/22D belongs to the frame type of products, and due to the presence of a hook fastening, it is suitable for most car brands. The frame of this model is made of high quality steel 1.2 mm, followed by galvanizing and painting, to provide the brushes with better resistance to aggressive impacts. environment. The blade made of natural rubber compound with graphite impregnation technology minimizes vibrations and slippage.
The design of the metal rocker arms provided in the Mui-Champ wipers provides maximum pressure of the rubber brush to the surface in six points, which guarantees the best cleaning of the car windshield.
3 Heyner Exclusive Graphite
Best price
Country: Germany
Average price: 320 rubles.
Rating (2019): 4.5
Opens our rating very interesting representative skeleton builders. The first and very important feature is the ability to buy an adapter for any leash, which means that you can use the model on almost any car. The second feature is a replaceable rubber band. On the one hand, it is convenient - you do not need to buy a complete unit, and this is a significant savings in money. On the other hand, the brush can simply freeze to the glass, while the metal base will make a passage and scratch the glass. Yes, and it does not clean Exclusive Graphit in the best way.
However, the versatility low cost and replacement belt make this offer one of the best on the market. The only thing that the owners do not like about all of the above is the sliding of the rubber tread when the wipers move. In their reviews, users note that at high intensity. wiper operation, the rubber band of the wiper may slip off the guides. This is especially pronounced in winter period when the frame wipers are subjected to excessive loads.
2 Champion Aerovantage
Most Reliable
Country: Hungary
Average price: 375 rubles.
Rating (2019): 4.6
Champion products enjoy well-deserved popularity among domestic motorists. The Aerovantage series includes a huge number of models of different lengths and with all possible types of attachment, so it will not be difficult to choose a brush for your car. Unfortunately, there are also disadvantages. The main one is not the best best quality glass cleaning. You can also complain about the massiveness of the structure, which can lead to loosening of the hinges.
However, it is precisely this "flaw" that many owners who have chosen the framed Champion Aerovantage for their car consider to be a huge advantage. Judging by the reviews, in winter these massive wipers cope better than others with snow and melted ice. And even if the wiper needs to make more than one pass to ensure quality review, due to their reliability, Aerovantage frame brushes have every right to be among the best models in our rating. In winter, this quality comes in very handy.
Comparison of the three main types of wiper blades: framed, frameless and hybrid.
|
pros |
Minuses |
|
|
frame |
Most common They have excellent rigidity and adhere well to glass Plastic parts are not subject to corrosion |
- Metal models are susceptible to corrosion and freeze more If the rocker arms are made of cheap plastic, play quickly appears and cleaning efficiency is significantly reduced. |
|
frameless |
Relatively high frost resistance Fewer moving parts means more reliability Have less distortion when moving on glass Quieter than frame |
Not universal, which means you can only purchase and use brushes designed for your car |
|
Hybrid |
Compact as frameless models Have excellent rigidity Best aerodynamics High reliability and service life Good adhesion to glass |
- High price |
1 Bosch Twin
Best cleaning
A country:
Average price: 620 rubles.
Rating (2019): 4.8
Bosch is a leader in many areas of our lives. Their products did not disappoint in the field of car wiper blades. Due to the narrow and rigid blade this model Works great on tough stains on glass. It knocks down both fine dirt and ice, not to mention the usual rain. But it should be borne in mind that Bosch Twin has one significant drawback - relatively rapid wear. Yes, due to its rigidity, the brush does an excellent job of removing dirt, but it also wears out much faster than softer competitors. Thus, we have an excellent “framework” for those who are ready to change their wipers 2-3 times a year in order to provide themselves with an excellent overview.
At the same time, the high strength of the cleaning protector of the wiper does not harm the windshield or rear windows at all, and in winter it makes this wiper one of the most effective among the frame brushes. In their reviews, the owners point out one feature of operation - if the washer nozzle moistens the entire surface of the glass where the rubber band passes (good spraying), then the cleaning is perfect, and even heavy pollution can be removed in one pass, and this significantly increases the service life.
Best Frameless Wiper Blades
Frameless brushes - more modern type wipers. Engineers tried to get rid of the system of rocker arms and hinges in favor of pre-curved plates, between which the brush blade is clamped. This option is more reliable and better aerodynamics. In addition, the lower weight puts less stress on the drives, which means they will last a little longer. But it should be borne in mind that frameless wipers are created specifically for each specific car model. So, be careful - not all participants in our rating are suitable for your car.
5 Artways
Best price
Country: China
Average price: 260 rubles.
Rating (2019): 4.0
Owners who have chosen Artway frameless wipers are completely satisfied not only with their characteristics, but also with an affordable price. Thanks to the use of stainless spring steel in the clamping mechanism, the rubber comb adheres tightly to the windshield of the car, ensuring effective removal of water, dirt, snow and melting ice. And this is despite the rather small weight of the frameless wiper.
In winter, Teflon treatment (the rubber tread has a protective layer) gives the wiper a good competitive advantage over similar wiper models. The presence in the kit of adapters for different types of fasteners ensures the applicability of these brushes in almost all brands of cars, maximizing target audience. Maintaining elasticity during deep freezing (up to -40 ° C) is also strong point these budget wipers.
4 ClimAir
Most durable
Country: Germany
Average price: 900 rubles.
Rating (2019): 4.4
For nearly 50 years, this company has been in the car accessories business, and its frameless wiper blades deserve special attention. The rubber component is made of natural rubber and impregnated with graphite using a special technology. They perform their functions perfectly, do not creak and withstand temperatures from -40 ° C to 80 ° C without loss of their performance. Before a complete replacement, the wipers can make almost 1.5 million strokes on the windshield, effectively removing dirt and precipitation.
The owners consider their choice in favor of ClimAir wipers to be the right and rational decision. The ability to replace the rubber band in a frameless brush not only significantly increases the service life of the wipers, but also saves the user money - a high-quality rubber band for a windshield wiper will cost disproportionately higher. The reviews also note the excellent aerodynamics of the wiper, due to which it is better pressed against the glass by the oncoming air flow. Impregnation of the tread, unlike external spraying, allows you to maintain the declared properties longer, despite the gradual erasure of the working edge of the gum.
3 Valeo Silencio X.TRM
High reliability
Country: France
Average price: 930 rubles.
Rating (2019): 4.4
Wipers from Valeo can hardly be called outsiders. Yes, the cleaning quality is far from perfect. Yes, they stand like an airplane. But they last for years! Neither ultraviolet nor temperature changes have a noticeable effect on the quality of cleaning. The only thing that can force the car owner to replace them is the banal abrasion of the tape, but no one is immune from this. Also to the merits is to write down the cunning shape of the brush, due to which water is expelled faster at a higher speed - it will be extremely useful for those who often travel outside the city.
For timely replacement, the owner can install a special sensor sticker on the windshield, which, under the influence of ultraviolet radiation, will gradually change its color. The critical condition of the rubber bands of the wiper occurs with a bright yellow tint of the indicator, which indicates the need for replacement. In their reviews, the owners consider the presence of a sensor a clear advantage. Timely installation of new brushes during high-speed driving will eliminate poor-quality wiper operation, which will always provide the driver with excellent visibility on the highway.
2 Bosch Aerotwin
The highest quality cleaning
A country: Germany (made in China)
Average price: 660 rubles.
Rating (2019): 4.6
At first glance, brushes from Bosch are just perfect. Firstly, they are suitable for a huge number of cars, even without the use of adapters. Secondly, they have best performance for cleaning glass. This is due to the excellent pressure and the proprietary composition of the rubber band, which copes well with dried mud in summer and does not freeze in winter. Finally, the Aerotwin wipers are simply quiet, which is also important. And everything would be fine, but after 5-6 months the quality of cleaning drops significantly, which means that you will have to change the consumable very often.
Despite the moderate operating life, Bosch wipers Aerotwin are in stable demand, especially from the owners of cars such as Skoda SuperB, Kia Ceed, Touran, Volkswagen Caddy and some other brands, because they are ideally suited to the parameters of the windshield of these cars. For this reason frameless wipers spend their resource more economically, which, judging by the feedback from the owners, increases the duration of their effective use.
1 Denso WB Flat Blade
Country: France
Average price: 1690 rubles.
Rating (2019): 4.7
These frameless brushes from Denso are not in vain at the top positions in the tests of popular automotive magazines. First of all, the presence in the kit catches the eye a large number adapters, due to which you can install the WB-Flat Blade on a lot of cars. Also, the wipers can be praised for the excellent pressure provided by the aerodynamic shape, and excellent quality cleaning. Even with dry dirt, the model will cope without problems. Finally, it is worth noting the non-freezing frame, which is very useful for operation in winter conditions.
Consumers who have chosen Denso WB-Flat Blade wipers for their car are satisfied with their functionality. Many reviews note the confidently good quality of work, as well as the decent durability of these wipers. The rubber band of the frameless brush is quite resistant not only to abrasion, but also has sufficient strength to adequately withstand loads. winter operation.
The best hybrid wiper blades
Finally, we got to the most modern wiper blades. hybrid type- this is something in between, between wireframe and frameless brushes. They have a system of rocker arms and hinges, which provides them with an excellent fit to the surface, on top of which there is a plastic casing that reduces friction against the incoming air. Thus, the engineers were able to combine the advantages of two older technologies. Of course, the cost is slightly higher, but this disadvantage is more than offset by a longer service life.
5 Goodyear Hybrid
Counterfeit protection. High build quality
Country: USA
Average price: 620 rubles.
Rating (2019): 4.5
Goodyear Hybrid wipers can only be installed on vehicles with left hand drive and are designed for windshield wipers with a mounting type for HOOK brushes. The design is made in full accordance with hybrid models - the frame part is hidden in an aerodynamic casing, which, moreover, gives the car a more stylish appearance. The metallized case is very reliable and resistant to loads, well protects the rubber protector from damage. At the same time, the build quality of the Goodyear Hybrid wipers can be safely called one of the best on the market. It should also be noted that there is protection against fakes - windshield wipers are among the few models in which it is implemented at the proper level.
As for the work itself, it practically does not cause any complaints from the owners. Thanks to the graphite coating on the working blade of the tape, the windshield wipers operate silently, without gaps and demonstrate effective cleaning even on a dry windshield. In winter, the brushes do an excellent job with snow and melting ice, while they are almost silent and do not freeze, losing the mobility of the frame.
4 MTF-Light Hybrid U-Hook
High wear resistance
Country: South Korea
Average price: 540 rubles.
Rating (2019): 4.6
The South Korean manufacturer, ranked 5th in the world in the production of car wiper blades, has created the MTF-Light Hybrid U-Hook by order of car assembly concerns. Of course, some of the products also end up on the aftermarket. Compliance with the conditions of Russian operation makes these wipers quite popular among our owners. various cars. Brushes are installed on almost any brand - the U-Hook mount with an adapter may well be universal.
The high resistance to abrasion of the gum provides a unique component composition that allows you to keep the brush soft, despite the frost. Owner reviews especially often point to excellent performance during the winter months. The rubber protector of the wiper is evenly pressed frame mechanism and when sliding on the glass does not emit extraneous sounds. Hidden in an elegant casing, it is reliably protected from precipitation and always remains mobile in winter conditions, providing the driver with excellent visibility.
3 Trico NeoForm
Quietest
A country: USA (Made in Mexico)
Average price: 560 rubles.
Rating (2019): 4.6
The model from Mexico opens the rating of hybrid wiper blades. It should be said right away that the representative of the New World does not cope with pollution in the best way. Yes, cleaning is uniform, but not perfect. Here and there there are small annoying stripes. Thus, graphite-coated natural rubber only adds value, not quality.
At the same time, the brushes do not break out of the budget segment into the “highest echelon”, which cannot but rejoice us, as buyers. The symmetrical spoiler (suitable for installation on "right-hand drive" cars) of the windshield wiper tightly presses the rubber band at speed. Trico NeoForm perform well in harsh winter conditions. Despite the ice and snow, the wipers clean just as well as they do during the warmer months. Judging by the reviews, the only significant disadvantage many consider it impossible to rotate the rubber element - the protector is glued into the frame and cannot be replaced.
2 Denso Wiper Blade
The highest quality cleaning
Country: France
Average price: 760 rubles.
Rating (2019): 4.8
Brush from Denso again takes the lead. The disadvantages of the model include only a relatively high cost, while the equipment, information in Russian and convenient installation give pleasure even before use. The quality of cleaning, by the way, is at a very decent level. Stripes appear only after long-term operation under constant temperature fluctuations. All in all, a great model if you're willing to put up with the high price tag.
Moreover, the cost is fully justified, and some owners in their reviews refer to them as just janitors with a fair price. The presence of a spoiler guarantees an excellent clamping of the brushes on the track, and the rocker frame ensures an even distribution of forces. At the same time, the mechanism is reliably hidden from such external factors like snow and water, which means that in winter the elastic will be pressed as evenly and efficiently as in summer.
1 Heyner Hybrid Graphite
The best ratio of price and quality
Country: Germany
Average price: 530 rubles.
Rating (2019): 4.9
It is difficult to call glass after cleaning with these brushes perfectly clean. The center is always cleaned well, but the periphery, in case of serious pollution, clearly receives little attention. However, the Hybrid Graphit is an excellent choice, costing even less than other frame brushes, while offering a universal attachment that fits most cars and better cleaning performance.
But not only affordable price and versatility brought Heyner Hybrid Graphit is the leader in the hybrid brush category. Judging by the feedback from the owners, the excellent aerodynamics of the case enhances the pressure of the rubber tread against the glass, improving the removal of precipitation and dirt at speed. The waterproof shroud keeps the wipers working in the winter, and the graphite coating on the wiper blade makes them one of the quietest wipers around.
The Best Wiper Blades for Winter
For winter operation, special frame-type windshield wipers have been created. They have working surface protected by a special cover. Thanks to this design, it is possible to prevent the formation of ice at the contact point. The main disadvantage winter brushes can be called vibration at high speed due to high aerodynamic drag.
5 OSAWA SW
The most reliable
A country: Japan (made in China)
Average price: 750 rubles.
Rating (2019): 4.5
One of best wipers for winter from the Japanese manufacturer OSAWA perfectly cope with their task in the most extreme weather conditions. The brushes are in covers, so that the frame clamping mechanism does not clog and retains mobility. The rubber tread just ends with a tapered blade, not a herringbone. Because of this feature, windshield wipers do not retain water, and therefore do not freeze to the glass. As a result, there is no need to retract the leashes during long parking.
The wipers work quietly, without squeaks and gaps, maintaining their softness in any frost. Owners using the OSAWA SW in the winter have not been able to point out any shortcomings in their reviews. A typical attachment to HOOK leashes with the help of adapters becomes universal, so there are practically no cars in Russia on which these windshield wipers could not be installed.
4 AVS Winter Line
Buyer's Choice
A country: USA (made in China)
Average price: 370 rubles.
Rating (2019): 4.7
An excellent winter blade with a protective rubber cover will ensure the high-quality operation of the windshield wipers in snowfalls or a blizzard. The metal frame skeleton is not clogged with snow and melting ice, thanks to which it always remains operational in the most difficult moments of winter. The wipers work perfectly - the uniform pressure of the rubber comb ensures reliable removal of precipitation and dirt from the windshield, leaving no streaks or streaks. The quality of cleaning is in many ways similar to more expensive analogues, which is why AVS Winter Line has a serious competitive advantage - wipers use on domestic market stable demand.
As for installation, thanks to the adapters included in the kit, the wipers are suitable for installation, with rare exceptions, on almost any car. In the reviews of the owners there are no even the slightest complaints about the operation of the brushes. They are quiet, last a long time and do their job perfectly. The only thing that some users point to is the coating on the gum blade, which wears out the fastest during operation. If you use a graphite impregnated tread, the life of the wipers would be much longer.
3 SKYWAY
The most affordable price
Country: China
Average price: 350 rubles.
Rating (2019): 4.7
At the most favorable price, you can purchase a winter SKYWAY wiper blade standard. To protect against freezing, the manufacturer has developed special composition rubber, in which graphite and silicon oxide are introduced. The frame of the wiper is protected by a special casing from moisture and dirt. Therefore, in any frost, the brush evenly adheres to the windshield. Cleaning is easy thanks to good glide. The graphite surface also improves the aerodynamic properties of the wiper, so there is no strong noise and vibration during operation. Thanks to high technology and quality control, the manufacturer managed to create a durable material.
Domestic car owners in the reviews indicate the real properties of brushes for winter SKYWAY standard. The advantages include low price, nice design, secure frame. Brushes cannot be called durable, they only do their job for 1 season.
2 Airline AWB-W-550
The best domestic brush for winter
Country Russia
Average price: 530 rubles.
Rating (2019): 4.7
High-quality winter wipers Airline AWB-W-550 are made in our country. The frame type brush has excellent aerodynamic properties, it perfectly removes dirt and snow at low temperatures. One of the reasons for the good cleansing properties is the use of artificial rubber, created using innovative anti-age technology. When creating the material, ozone is used, and the surface of the rubber band is covered with a layer of graphite. The result is not only low friction, but also quiet operation. The janitor can be used all year round, while maintaining long term services.
Users in the reviews note the resistance of the Airline AWB-W-550 brushes to freezing, high-quality cleaning of the windshield from dirt and ice. Of the minuses, car owners distinguish a deterioration in cleaning ability after a season of operation.
1 ALCA Winter
Optimal combination of price and quality
Country: Germany
Average price: 590 rubles.
Rating (2019): 4.8
The German ALCA Winter wiper blade is distinguished by an affordable price. This winter model created on the basis of a frame janitor. A distinctive feature of the brush is the preservation of the softness of the working surface with a strong decrease in temperature. Structurally, this was achieved by creating a special profile of the rubber band. Also used a new formula in the manufacture of rubber. The presence of a waterproof cover prevents frostbite of the frame parts. It was possible to increase the wear resistance of the working part due to the coating of the tape with nano-graphite. To increase the service life of winter wipers, it is necessary to replace them with summer models with the advent of spring.
Domestic car owners in the reviews write about such advantages of ALCA Winter wipers as accessibility, lack of icing, good cleaning ability. The disadvantages of motorists include an unattractive appearance when installed on ordinary cars.
How to choose wipers
When choosing wiper blades, you should not only pay attention to the design, but also to other characteristics.
- One of the most important parameters is the length of the wiper. It is best to buy wipers of the length recommended by the manufacturer. First of all, this applies to cars with two brushes on the windshield. However, it has become popular among motorists to select different-sized models. So, on some Mitsubishi models, you can see wipers 350 and 650 mm long. Daewoo owners Lanos instead of two brushes with a length of 475 mm, models with a size of 450 and 500 mm are installed. It is important that the wipers do not touch each other during operation.
- When replacing wiper blades, you should also look at the mount. The most popular option remains the hook, but there are side pins, buttons, bayonets, etc. Usually, a set of adapters comes with new brushes.
- Before buying, you should make an external inspection of the frame. There should be no chips or burrs on metal elements, and cracks on plastic.
- Concerning appearance rubber band, then you should not put special emphasis on the color of the material. Some manufacturers add graphite, which makes the rubber black. Others introduce silicone into the composition, so the working surface becomes light.
- Some car enthusiasts buy heated wipers. They not only spend more money on the purchase of consumables, but also rework the on-board network. The effect of such a refinement is doubtful even among experts. Heating on the brushes can only warm the place of contact with the glass. The rest of the windshield will have to be defrosted by warming up the car.
