04.04.2016

Frame or demon frame wipers?

The car originally had frame wipers, after replacing them I bought a demon frame brushes wiper. I share my opinion, which is better to take frame or frameless wipers?

Frameless brushes- These are slightly curved wipers for a greater fit to the windshield. Their advantage is the minimum aerodynamic drag.

Prices for frameless wiper blades are varied and can be found on any budget. They differ from each other in various bells and whistles such as the shape of the spoiler, mounting, wear sensors, design and composition of the rubber blade.

Frame brushes are a rubber brush on a metal frame. It allows the brush to fit snugly against the glass. They also vary in price and depend on the number of “bells and whistles”.

Now about the main thing - which is better frame or frameless wipers? The answer is for everyone. I had both frameless and framed, and both coped with the task. But, personally, I liked the frame wipers more, because in winter, when the wipers freeze or are littered with snow, it is more convenient to lift them by the frame than by a thin strip.

P.S. It is worth remembering that the wiper blades are consumable and they change almost every year. Therefore, you can test frame and frameless wipers every season. What you like - only God knows.

By the way, who loves fast driving in bad weather, it is better to take wipers with a spoiler, this will provide a greater fit to the glass from the wind flow.

Now I generally take the simplest frame wipers for 190 rubles a piece and change them after the winter to new ones. The original for the car costs 1600 rubles a set. It took them two years.

Safety while driving consists of many facts, ranging from the health of any node vehicle and ending with the smallest details.

TOP frameless wiper blades.

The importance of windshield wipers

Naturally, first of all, safety depends on the skills of the driver, his calmness and compliance with all the rules. traffic. But, if the technique fails, even the greatest experience will not come to the rescue. Note that now we are not talking about the most terrible situations, such as brake failure, or driving on ice. We are talking about a small but very important review. Agree, you can’t move if the windshield “transmits” a blurry “image”. It is in this case that the same windshield wipers play a big role. Right now we are going to talk about them.

The best frameless brushes

The most modern wipers are frameless. What does it mean? No more "rocker" system. Engineers abandoned the "rocker" system, which includes hinges. They went the other way and chose pre-curved plates, between which the brush blade is sandwiched. Note that such wipers not only significantly improve the appearance of the vehicle, but also do an excellent job with their main task - cleaning from rain, snow and fog without streaks and other troubles that could impair visibility.

Important! Frameless brushes weigh much less than frame brushes. That is, they load the drives much less, thereby extending their service life. Also, keep in mind that these brushes are rarely non-contact. As a rule, they are made for a specific car brand.

Top best

So, which frameless wiper blades are better, this rating will “tell”:

These wipers cannot be called outsiders. The cleaning quality is good, but not the best. And yes, they are quite expensive. BUT! They serve for years. Once changed and forgot about the wipers for a long time. They are not affected by cold or heat. They are not afraid of any temperature fluctuations. The quality of cleaning does not change in a wide variety of weather conditions. By the way, they clean the window much faster (that is, they work more intensively, which again can be due to a lower weight compared to conventional brushes). Great choice for drivers who often move along the highway - provide a high level of visibility with heavy rain and when driving at high speed.

Advantages:

• excellent water drainage when driving at high speed;
• high level of reliability.

Of the shortcomings - a rather high cost.

This best device at first sight. Undoubtedly, these wipers are perfectly combined with many cars (and there is no need to use special adapters). Also different high level the quality of cleaning the windshield, which is due to the special composition of rubber, as well as strong pressure. By the way, these wipers do not freeze in winter time year, and in the summer they do an excellent job even with dried mud. In addition, they work very quietly. It would seem - the best option. But ... after six months of work, the quality of their cleaning is halved.

Advantages:

• excellent work in all weather conditions;
• very quiet (virtually silent);
• fit many cars.

The disadvantage in the form of a relatively low service life calls into question their acquisition.

Not just because they are ranked third in the ranking. Considered one of the best frameless wipers. Completed big amount adapters, thanks to which they are suitable for installation on various vehicles. They are distinguished by excellent pressure, high-quality glass cleaning, as well as aerodynamic shape. Quickly and without problems cope with dried dirt on windshield. Do not freeze, which will be highly appreciated by car owners in winter period of the year.

Advantages:

• the presence of adapters;
• high quality cleaning;
• more than a good price.

Pretty durable wipers. Thanks to graphite filling, up to two million cleaning operations are performed. Hull processed special means protecting against corrosion. Good clamp, which contributes to high-quality glass cleaning. The complete absence of creaks.

Advantages:

• corrosion protection;
• graphite filling;
• long service life;
• no squeaks.

The disadvantage is the rather high cost.

Alca Winter

Copes well with the elements - frost,. Differs in low cost. Real hard workers who can easily cope with heavy loads. Do not require cleaning even after prolonged standing. It can be noted from the name that it is better to use them in the winter season. In the summer, their tires quickly become unusable.

Advantages:

• the use of German technologies in the manufacture, which positively affects the quality of the product;
• high level of confrontation low temperatures and other adverse weather conditions.

Flaws:

• rather large dimensions;
• suitable for use exclusively in winter, otherwise it will quickly become unusable.

Wipers are a consumable accessory for your car. For comparison, tires, with careful handling, can last 5 years or more, but the rubber on the wipers is erased in a few months. That is why they have to be changed all the time. Once again, when choosing windshield wiper blades, you wonder again and again, which wipers are best suited? Let's try to figure it out with you.

Frame wipers

Framed wiper blades are usually made of plastic. A cleansing agent is attached to the base (skeleton). rubber band which does its job well. Despite the number of cleaning arms, and there may be 2, 3 or even 4, one single-piece cleaning tape is attached to them. It is thanks to its mobility that every detail of the wiper fits snugly against the glass.

They have another significant plus. This design allows you to avoid it entirely - you just need to buy a cleaning tape, which is easy to change with your own hands. Thus, you can save a lot!

So, let's look at the "pros" and "cons" of these wipers. Some of the benefits of framed wiper blades include:

• tight fit to the windshield, which improves the quality of cleaning;
• the possibility of purchasing a winter model;
• replacement of cleaning tapes.

But there are some "cons":

• snow and ice stick to ordinary wipers in winter, due to which the brushes become motionless;
• in case of icing, the wipers have to be cleaned for a long time until they begin to function normally;
• winter wipers do not adhere well to the windshield, which affects snow removal.

Frameless wipers

This model does not have a skeleton and a separate cleaning tape. It is a plastic bar with a clamping element inside it. Their advantage is in an attractive appearance, which looks more advantageous. Usually frameless models are produced under specific brand machines in order to most accurately repeat the bend of the windshield. But this applies to inexpensive products that can be purchased at the usual car market.

As for premium products, frameless wipers are produced using a special technology, so the brand of the car does not matter. But the length is important, so you need to take measurements before you go shopping. Which ones are better? It depends on how much you are willing to spend on windshield wipers.

The benefits of frameless brushes are:

1. Harmoniously combined with any brand of car.
2. Premium models are ideal for any car model.
3. Easy cleaning of ice and snow in the winter season.
4. Good aerodynamics.

These wipers also have their drawbacks:

1. If you buy inexpensive frameless wipers, you will have to select them for the brand of your car.
2. If you choose the wrong model, with passenger side dirt can be difficult to clean.
3. Premium wipers are quite expensive.

Hybrid brushes

The developers also often thought about which wipers are better, so they created hybrid windshield wipers. This is a mixed model that successfully combines the frame of classic wipers and a compact plastic spoiler, which was given to them by frameless wipers. Since it is a hybrid, it looks different from classical model. If you decide to replace your wipers with these, you can achieve an enhanced aerodynamic effect that will positively affect the cleaning of the windshield surface. The tighter the wipers fit, the better the cleaning will be. This is especially true for cars with a convex windshield.

Significant drawback who have hybrid wipers lies in their very high cost. But their service life, in comparison with other models, is several times higher. But this is on condition that you buy original products, and not Chinese fake. They retain their original appearance for about a year, even with intensive use. But which option is the best? Let's try to answer this question by considering the design features of the wipers.

What to look for when choosing?

Rubber is one of the main components of wipers. She works in very harsh conditions. This is especially true in the winter season: constant fluctuations temperatures, changeable humidity, ingress of sand and earth, chemicals that fall on it during washing. Therefore, the best will be the gum that has its own characteristics. It should be soft and fit well. convex glass. But at the same time, be so tough as not to smear dirt, but to remove it from the surface of the glass.

When choosing brushes, many motorists pay attention to the mount, and for good reason. Today there are 8 most common types of fasteners, so it's very easy to get confused in them!

So which ones are better to choose? There are two options for solving the problem when choosing. You can purchase a set of wipers with specific mountings specifically for your car model. True, such brushes will cost quite a lot, but they are worth it.

The second option is to choose wipers with universal mounts. Frameless models can boast a wide range in this area. They are suitable for any car, so you do not have to rack your brains when buying. But such brushes have low aerodynamics, so they do not cope very well with heavy dirt.

Pay attention to the dimension. Usually right and left wipers have different lengths. And this means that when choosing, you need to carefully select the size.

There is no universal answer to the question: “Which wipers are better?”. Each model has its own advantages and disadvantages. Nevertheless, framed wiper blades have so far been and remain the most popular. But after the advent of hybrid wipers, which combine the advantages of the two models, the popularity of framed wipers has declined slightly.

Ideally, if you purchase wipers designed specifically for your brand of car. Then they are guaranteed to do their job perfectly. And don't forget to change your windshield wipers at least once a year! This required condition for quality work.

25.01.2014

Many pages of various forums and sites are written on the topic, which brushes are better? Framed or frameless? Where they write one thing, where they write another! Let's try and figure this out.

To draw some conclusions, we need to understand the structure of frame and frameless (brushes), and only then we will be able to identify the advantages of one over the other.

Frame Wiper Blades

Framed wiper blades are a skeleton to which a cleaning rubber band is attached. In other words, rocker arms extend from the wiper leash (there are 2,3,4 of them depending on the model), to which a cleaning tape is attached, despite the fact that the tape is in free circulation (it can move back and forth). Each wiper arm is movable and, due to this, is able to fit snugly against the glass.

Due to their design, the wiper blades do not have to be completely replaced, but can only be replaced by replacing the cleaning tape. This is undoubtedly a plus, because. the cost of the tape from the set of new wipers differs markedly in favor of the first.

This design does not have a skeleton, there is no separate tape. Frameless wipers are a tape, inside of which there is a clamping element (for example, a steel plate). Frameless, unlike frame ones, clearly win in the appearance of the car. Most often (from the lowest price category) frameless wipers are produced purely according to car models in order to repeat the bend of the windshield as much as possible. But from the premium segment, frameless brushes are made using special technologies where you don’t need to know the brand of the car, but you need to know the required length of the wipers (the length of the wipers VAZ 2114, 2115, 2113).

What is better? Framed or frameless?

In fact, everyone chooses his own for himself, which is why there are long conversations on the forums, where they do not find a clear answer. We, in turn, will not argue that one or the other is better, we will simply tell you the advantages of one over the other, and you will choose for yourself. Agreed? Then let's go!

Frame wipers

Frame wipers lose in their own way appearance, but they have a greater pressing force against the windshield due to the structure of the rocker arms, which undoubtedly affects the quality of glass cleaning for the better.

But the complex system of rocker arms also has a negative point: in winter, in snowy weather, the rocker arms are covered with ice, the wiper becomes motionless and oaky - respectively. There is only one way out of this - to warm up, standing in the cold to clear the ice from the wipers until the rocker arms move freely.

Therefore, for the winter they came up with frame wipers with closed rocker arms. In other words, the entire skeleton of the janitor is hidden in a plastic casing, where snow and moisture do not penetrate - accordingly, the rocker arms are always mobile and the janitor cleans well. But this system also has a small minus - on high speed, due to the "winged" structure of such wipers downforce to the windshield drops noticeably, which negatively affects the quality of glass cleaning.

The advantage over frameless is also the ability to change cleaning tapes. In frameless wipers, the tape does not change, but the brush assembly changes.

Frameless wipers

The appearance of these wipers is in harmony with any car, rather than the skeleton of carcasses.

These wipers of the economy segment must be selected according to the brand of the car, because. each car has its own windshield shape, respectively, the janitor has its own bend. Therefore, with cheap wipers, it often happens that the brush does not press well on the passenger side, and therefore the dirt is not cleaned. Nothing to do with such brushes, only change to quality ones. The premium segment promises us to work perfectly on any car, the main thing is to choose the length, but the price of such brushes is over 1000 rubles.

Also, the advantage of frameless is - easy cleaning of ice in winter, it is enough to bend the wipers a couple of times and all the ice will fall off.

Another advantage of such wipers is good aerodynamics. Those. with increasing speed, their downforce does not fall.

I hope you understand everything and you will do right choice. We also recommend that you read the article: In it, you will learn how to choose the right brushes, what you need to know, which companies should be preferred.

Frameless wiper blades are not new to the automotive accessory market. They were developed back in the 80s of the last century. If the windshield has a convex shape, then it seemed logical to the engineers to bend the metal elements inside the rubber band. Also, the brushes were made wider and gave them transverse rigidity. The leash attachment was created directly on the product.

With the development of the automotive industry, both windshields and their curvature increased. Along with this, the wipers also grew in length. More so-called swings were added to the design, which provided pressure to the glass. The wipers themselves have become more bulky. This negatively affected the aerodynamic characteristics, as well as reliability. Due to the large size, visibility deteriorated and noise increased.

Frameless modern solutions

It was and still is in the 80s. Today it is a completely different design.

Although they are called frameless, but this is not entirely true. The frame is present. But instead traditional system from the rocker arms in the new solution, a specially curved spring element made of steel was used. This mechanism is made in the form of strips. The frame is hidden inside a rubber band.

The brush has a profile that was created for a specific glass. The curvature is maintained throughout the life of the product and does not change due to various constantly changing loads and temperature conditions.

High tech product

Frameless wiper blades may seem simple, but they are a very high-tech product. The plate is one of the most important parts in all quality products. As for the second important part, the rubber band, it is made of graphite. Rubber gives the brushes elasticity, and graphite makes them more wear-resistant and protects against damaging solar radiation better. Thanks to the composition with graphite, the brush will not creak when moving on glass, and will also cope with water perfectly.

Advantages of frameless brushes

The main advantage is the uniform pressing of the wiper's working edge to the glass.

This improves the efficiency and quality of the cleaning process. This effect was achieved thanks to a specially calculated profile of the steel strip. This profile corresponds exactly to the curvature of the glass. Good frameless brushes can have up to 15 segments, with which the design changes. The clamping force is controlled at 32 points.

Improved aerodynamics and noise reduction

Another advantage of such solutions is in aerodynamics. So, a structure without a frame, even with a spoiler, will be lower than a traditional wiper. This makes it possible to significantly reduce drag and which tears the structure from the glass. This is very true for those cars where the wiper circuit is hinged and where each brush is different. large sizes. The airflow passing through the monolithic and low construction will cause significantly less noise than if it were to pass through the tricky mechanisms of a traditional brush. So, when driving at a speed of 100 km / h, this noise can reach significant values.

Frameless brushes in winter: what you need

Another significant advantage is that these structures are practically not subject to freezing. In classic wipers, the water in the hinges quickly freezes, the pressing force against the glass decreases, and the mechanism leaves dirty streaks on the glass. In a frameless product, this is not. A slight decrease in performance is possible, but this only happens if ice forms on the rubber. If this happens, it will not be difficult to clean such a brush. There are also products with electric heating. However, the cost of such models starts from 50 US dollars.

Disadvantages of a frameless wiper

The first and most basic disadvantage is the lack of versatility. Due to the fact that steel plates are made with a curve, they can only be installed on panes that have the same curvature. So, for each specific glass, or rather a short model, there is a brush. Due to the fact that the characteristics are different, on some vehicles the product may not clean all areas. Often this place is near the right pillar of the body.

Also, several centimeters of the brush can hang above the glass. But this is not a marriage, but a design feature of the janitor.

Another minus is the lack of unification in the fastener brackets. So, each manufacturer different cars offers only those intended for specific model frameless wiper blades.

Market Review

Every person wants to have the best for himself. Therefore, you need to tell which models of frameless glass cleaners are the best. You should also decide what is the difference between affordable and expensive products. For many, the ratio of quality and price for a particular model is important.

A test was conducted during which brushes from various price ranges competed.

Among the test participants are brands such as Avtovirazh, Bosch wipers, Champion, Phantom, RainBlade Select and Xopc Ballistic.

How the test was done

To get acquainted with the products, they were subjected to the first demonstration test. So, each model had to pass once on the glass surface and remove fatty kefir. Then, after 30 seconds of operation, the brush had to work on clean glass with washer fluid.

This small and simple test should show everything that was originally laid down by the manufacturer. All models were new and in packaging. The wipers were also checked for crushing. And the sharpness of the working edge and the clamping force were also checked. In addition, the noise level during operation was evaluated.

"Autovirage": market value - 159 rubles.

This is the most budget brush, which is only on the market. modern market. The quality is the same as the price. After one pass over the glass smeared with kefir, a fan trail formed on the lower left edge of the working area. At the top right, this brush has made a stroke along the radius.

This product failed to completely remove traces of kefir without the use of windshield washer fluid - a noticeable film of fat remained. But in terms of noise, this product proved to be very good - when working on clean glass, the brush, of course, creaks, but these sounds are not sharp and you can’t hear them from the cabin.

For 159 rubles, motorists get four adapters - this makes it possible to mount these brushes on most cars with various mounts.

Bosch Aerotween - 489 rubles

At first glance, from the packaging it may seem that these Bosch windshield wipers are fake. But no, the product is real. They performed well in the test. After one pass, there were no traces left. The brush cleaned the middle part of the working area completely without connecting the washer. Only a film of fat remained on the edges.

Acoustic characteristics - on top. There are practically no squeaks on the cleaned glass.

As for the set, famous brand offers mounting the device on a leash with a hook. One mounting option is still not enough. But we can say that these are the best frameless wiper blades, although there are other good models.

Champion Contact: $629

This is the most expensive model which was tested in the test. However, the price is fully justified. The quality of work is on a par with Bosch products. No defects were seen here. The area in the middle of the brush was cleaned even without Noise during operation.

Phantom: 265 rubles

This brush is almost the same as the "Autovirage". After the passage, there was a “fan” and strokes along the radius of movement, and the radius here is in the upper part on the left. Cleaning without a washer is impossible - the film of fat is almost invisible, but it is there. Everything is better with noise. This product comes with three adapters.

RainBlade Select: $399

This new brand. There is no mark-up for branding yet, but it is worth buying these brushes. They are no worse than frameless Bosch or Champion wiper blades. After one pass, there were also no marks or radius smears left. In the middle, the dirt was also destroyed without the need for a washer. This model, like the brand, does not make noise. As for fasteners, here it is universal and suitable for all types of cars. The size of the brushes will also fit most models and brands.

Xopc Ballistic: $2.99

These are budget products. The brush did the job a little better than the "Auto circulation".

After the first pass, there are no fans, but one large smear on the work area remains. This product is not capable of washing off dirt without the use of a washer. In terms of acoustic characteristics, this is the noisiest and most creaky solution. Complete with four adapters and a cover for the lock.

About sizes

In addition to the design of products, their size is also important. If you purchase the wrong one, some problems may arise. If the size of the brushes is too large, then the contact force will drop a lot, which will contribute to poor cleaning. In addition, large brushes will go beyond the sealing rubber on the windshield and come off working surface. And one more problem - a large part will hit the driver's door.

If smaller wipers are chosen, then the main disadvantage is a smaller working area. In addition, a dirty area may form in the middle of the glass.